US Senate News:
Source: United States Senator for Maryland Chris Van Hollen
March 29, 2021
Proposal will tackle one of the biggest loopholes in the U.S. tax code, which subsidizes America’s wealthiest heirs
Today, U.S. Senator Chris Van Hollen (D-Md.), joined by Senators Cory Booker (D-N.J.), Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.), Sheldon Whitehouse (D-R.I.), and Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.), announced a new proposal to close the stepped-up basis income tax loophole – reforming one of the largest tax breaks in our federal tax code in order to support national investments that will benefit all Americans and build a more inclusive economy. This new proposed legislation, the Sensible Taxation and Equity Promotion (STEP) Act, addresses the stepped-up basis loophole by taxing unrealized capital gains when heirs inherit huge fortunes on which the original owner never paid income taxes.
“To build an economy that works for all Americans we must tackle the inequality in our tax system. The stepped-up basis loophole is one of the biggest tax breaks on the books, providing an unfair advantage to the wealthy heirs every year. This proposal will eliminate that loophole once and for all. It’s time to stop subsidizing massive inheritances for the rich and start investing in everyday Americans,” said Senator Van Hollen.
“It is absurd that our tax code allows many of our country’s wealthiest people to get away with never paying a cent in taxes on millions or even billions in capital gains income, while working people pay taxes on every check they receive,” said Senator Sanders. “It is not a radical idea to demand the wealthiest among us pay their fair share and that we put an end to a rigged tax code that disproportionately burdens working people. I am proud to join with Sen. Van Hollen as an original cosponsor of legislation that would close one of the most egregious tax loopholes in our code today.”
“As wealth inequality worsens, and American democracy degrades, it’s time to take a hard look at devices like ‘stepped-up basis’ that are unique to inherited estates,” said Senator Whitehouse.
“The wealthy have rigged our tax system and helped perpetuate massive inequities in our economy and society,” said Senator Warren. “Closing the stepped-up basis loophole on huge, inherited fortunes for the wealthiest Americans is one step in the right direction: getting the wealthy and well-connected to pay their fair share.”
“Generations of the US tax code subsidizing the richest households have entrenched an extraordinary wealth gap, especially by race,” said Senator Cory Booker. “Closing this huge tax loophole for the richest Americans will help reduce extreme wealth inequality in our country, particularly if its savings are used to advance ideas that further level the playing field – ideas like my baby bonds proposal to create and fund a savings account for every child born in the United States that can be used at age 18 to pay for wealth-building investments like higher education, buying a house, or starting a small business.”
The STEP Act is supported by: AFL-CIO, American Federation of Teachers, Americans for Tax Fairness, Coalition on Human Needs, Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME), Patriotic Millionaires, and NETWORK Lobby for Catholic Social Justice.
Working Americans pay taxes every year on their income. But the income tax is more optional for the wealthiest families, whose income often comes from inherited wealth rather than work. Income from wealth accumulation is supposed to be taxed as capital gains when someone sells an asset for more than what they paid for it. However, when someone dies with assets that increased in value during their lifetime, income taxes are never collected on these capital gains – even if their heirs sell the asset the next day.
This is called the “stepped-up basis” loophole, because it allows heirs to step up their cost basis in inherited property to match the value on the date of the previous owner’s death, meaning that only capital gains above that point could ever be subject to income taxes. This is one of the largest tax breaks in the entire federal tax code, with the Joint Committee on Taxation estimating that it is worth $41.9 billion in 2021 alone.
Every dollar of the tax break from tax-free stepped-up basis is a government subsidy for inherited wealth, and the bulk of that subsidy goes to the wealthiest family dynasties. Thanks to stepped-up basis, 55% of the wealth in estates worth more than $100 million has never been, and will never be, subject to any income taxes.
The STEP Act closes the stepped-up basis loophole by taxing unrealized capital gains when heirs inherit huge fortunes on which the original owner never paid income taxes. Under this proposed legislation, the tiny share of estates that owe the estate tax will not be subject to double taxation, because the income taxes paid under this bill will be deductible for estate tax purposes. The bill also includes special rules to ensure that wealthy families are not able to avoid the tax by abusing trusts. Lastly, the bill ensures that this change would only apply to the wealthiest of families, and protects small family farms and businesses, in part by exempting up to $1 million in unrealized capital gains from taxation under the bill.
The Senators welcome feedback on this discussion draft, particularly for the technical questions raised in the section-by-section explanation, and look forward to introducing this legislation formally in the coming months.
“America’s ultra-wealthy are taking advantage of a huge tax loophole today that the STEP Act will close. Unlike most of us who must pay tax on our wages when we earn them, the rich pay no tax as their vast property holdings skyrocket in value. When they die, those untaxed gains, sometimes worth billions of dollars, escape tax forever. The STEP Act will close this loophole and raise huge sums needed to help rebuild roads and bridges, improve schools, and combat climate change,” said Frank Clemente, Executive Director of Americans for Tax Fairness.
“The Biden Administration rightly wants to increase taxation on capital gains, the main form of income of the super rich. To do so successfully, it is crucial to close the major loophole: capital gains bequeathed to heirs escape taxation entirely. This proposal eliminates this loophole and ensures that wealthy inheritors pay their fair share,” said Emmanuel Saez, Professor of Economics at the University of California Berkeley.
“This proposal is another big step forward towards addressing one of the most inefficient and inequitable tax breaks on income generated by extraordinary fortunes. It would ensure that income produced by extraordinary wealth – large amounts of which currently escape any income tax whatsoever – is subject to income tax on capital gains. And the proposal suggests sound solutions to the detailed technical decisions needed to implement this policy well,” said Chye-Ching Huang, Executive Director of the Tax Law Center at NYU Law.
“I could be called the poster-child for the stepped-up basis. The Disney stocks I own have dramatically increased in value, but if I were to pass them on to my kids without selling them? No one would ever pay taxes on that. That wealth doesn’t disappear, so I don’t know why the responsibility to pay taxes on it should,” said Abigail Disney, member of the Patriotic Millionaires.
“Senator Van Hollen’s legislation closes what is perhaps the biggest loophole in the entire tax code – the provision letting the ultra-wealthy transfer to their heirs an unlimited amount of wealth that literally has never been and never will be subject to income tax. It’s a big reason why the tax code is so skewed in favor of the very wealthy. President Biden has repeatedly emphasized how critical closing this loophole is to ending the tax code’s favoritism of wealth over work. This is the year for Congress to act,” said Alexandra Thornton, Senior Director of Tax Policy, Center for American Progress.
“In his encyclical Fratelli Tutti, Pope Francis challenges all people to live in solidarity: ‘[This] means much more than engaging in sporadic acts of generosity. It means thinking and acting in terms of community.’ The Sensible Taxation and Equity Promotion Act requires that the few wealthiest Americans whose income comes from their wealth, not work, pay their fair share of taxes for the sake of the community. NETWORK Lobby is proud to support this bill to fuel investment in our economy, address the racial wealth gap, and move our nation towards actual solidarity,” said Sister Simone Campbell, SSS, Executive Director of NETWORK Lobby for Catholic Social Justice.
“The Coalition on Human Needs strongly supports the Sensible Taxation and Equity Promotion (STEP) Act. It will lead to a more progressive tax system by generating revenue from our country’s wealthiest individuals to help provide resources to fund human needs programs critical for those families who need them the most,” said Deborah Weinstein, Executive Director of the Coalition on Human Needs.
“This is an important bill. It sensibly addresses the most indefensible, glaring omission from the individual income tax base. It will enhance equity and economic efficiency and raise significant revenue from those with a demonstrated ability to pay,” said Harry L. Gutman, Former Chief of Staff of the Joint Committee on Taxation.
“Our federal tax code plays a major role in leveling the economic playing field — it can help the rich get richer, or help everyday people access a path to a better life,” said Randi Weingarten, President of the American Federation of Teachers. “It’s long past time to do away with a tax break that simply shields the wealthiest of Americans who simply transfer all their wealth generationally without any tax consequences. The Sensible Taxation and Equity Promotion (STEP) Act closes some of these income tax loopholes. Over the course of the COVID-19 pandemic, working families have faced incredible economic hardship, while billionaires have accumulated over $1.3 trillion in new wealth. By eliminating tax breaks that only benefit the wealthiest Americans, we grow up money to make the public investments in health care, education, and infrastructure that our country so desperately needs.”